Before Superbad took over 2007, there was Accepted — a 2006 comedy gem that quietly brought together a surprising cast: Justin Long, Blake Lively, and a very familiar-sounding Jonah Hill. The story follows Bartleby Gaines (Long), a high school slacker who gets rejected from every college he applies to. So, in classic early-2000s movie fashion, he fakes an acceptance letter, builds a fake website, recruits a fake faculty, and accidentally opens a very real fake college: the South Harmon Institute