Wear it alone or with a combination of sheer metallic shadows. Lorac Front of the Line Pro Eye Pencil in Charcoal, $20, ulta.com. The paddle-shaped tip makes it easy to go thick and graphic or ...

Charcoal gray is a subtle shade ... tone applied in an inverted triangle under the eye brightens the look. Always blend: whether it's your pencil or your eyeshadow, blending is your best ally ...

The gentlest of eye flicks here, a moody charcoal rather than a fierce black ... But it’s possible to go full-on sultry by layering with a pencil or shadow stick, going day to night with ...

Since it's built like a standard pencil, sharpen it to prevent dullness and get more product — and it's available in over 10 neutral and bright shades like intense charcoal, deep onyx ...

These Eye Pencils can be used to create a sharp line ... Emerald Green, Ripe Purple, Charcoal Black that helps you to get the look that you want. They are perfect to add a subtle hint of color ...